Should I have another baby? Tough call. In part I’m scared of childbirth second time after my first experience. But more than that, I’m simply scared to have a second child in case I can’t cope.

I wrote recently about some of the many varied and valid reasons for single-child families*. It had already racked up more than a hundred Facebook shares by the first afternoon of publishing, and it continues to be one of most popular ever. I suppose you could say it resonated with a few people.

*(Incidentally, it occurred to me following publication that I could have included quite a few more reasons for families not having a second baby; for example same-sex parents; IVF families; single-parent families…the list goes on and on;  I hope I did a reasonable job of covering the most common situations.)

I didn’t disclose my personal situation in the post, and had no real intention of doing so – mostly because I thought doing so may detract from the power of the message I wanted to convey:

For many, tragedy is at the heart of their so-called decision, whereas my own circumstances are not tragic.

Woman's Hands Holding Coffee Cup

But this week I stumbled across a message in a Facebook group, in which somebody appeared to be describing very similar feelings to my own. And it made me realise that far from discounting my attitude as irrelevant next to other heartbreaking scenarios, I really shouldn’t be comparing at all. If others are feeling similar, then I should be using my blog as a platform to open up this discussion. Even if all it leads to is acknowledgement from each other; validation; support.

So I’m breaking my silence. Suffice to say, the title of this post is lifted directly from my own relationship. Allow me to explain…

Birth Control After Baby

I’ve coined ‘The Second baby Mating Dance’ to describe the (arguably juvenile) attitude towards contraception taking place in my own home. Essentially, it’s where postpartum birth control looks a lot like this:

Months One ~Nine:


Month Ten:

We are not having another child right now. Absolutely not.

Month Eleven:

Okay, Pixie needs a sibling, so should we have a second baby? Maybe we should start thinking about it. After her birthday perhaps.

Should We Have a Second Baby? Siblings

Month Twelve:

Wow, how did she turn one already?! Should we have a second baby now? After Christmas maybe…

Month Thirteen:

As soon as she starts sleeping through

Month Fourteen:

Praise the Lord – she’s sleeping through! Let’s give it a shot!

Month Fifteen:

Wow, sleep regressions are tough. Also – not pregnant. (Is it wrong to be totally thrilled about this?) Perhaps we were being a little hasty…maybe we should wait just a little longer… Yep, let’s definitely take a break this month.

Month Sixteen:

She really does need a sibling though… We’re back on – let’s do it!

Should We Have a Second Baby? Siblings

Month Seventeen:

Feeling broody around new babies, deffo up for this! Alas – not pregnant. Actually a little disappointed.

…Cue Pixie’s worst night in months. Through the dense fug of sleep-deprivation, I’m seeing more clearly than I have in weeks: what in God’s name have I been thinking? I can’t have another child right now! ABSOLUTELY NOT!

Month Eighteen:

Husband is adamant Pixie needs a sibling. Jesus Christ. Off we half-heartedly go again… (Pretty sure these are not the emotions I should be feeling about trying to create another little person. Oops.)

Month Nineteen:

Not pregnant – HURRAH! (This is definitely the wrong attitude to have about extending our family. I need to give some serious consideration to precisely what is going on in my head…)

Scared to Have a Second Child

Given the success of the initial post and my own confusion/penchant for Baby Roulette, I’ve decided to share my complicated feelings about having a second child. Here’s a candid breakdown of my reasons for wavering:

1. A Second Baby = A New Baby

This is the easy bit to write, because in many ways I’d love another baby – of course I would!

Pixie will (one day) be a marvellous big sister, and I agree with my husband that she seems to bumble around at home missing something someone – she would adore a sibling, I’m quite confident in that.

Should We Have a Second Baby? Girl with baby shoes

And the idea of holding another baby in my arms? Delicious, of course! Even the pregnancy itself – I actively miss being pregnant sometimes. My first was blissful (yes, I know how lucky I am).

So yes, I am broody. And I can even accept that second time around I’ll be far better prepared. I’ll know what to expect; I’ll be more confident in how to take care of a newborn – and how to take of myself as a new mum (equally vital!). But the fear is there, threatening to overwhelm and engulf me…I’m so apprehensive, about so many things.

It could be fabulous and complete our family. And yet…

2. Trauma

I wrote about this in the first post, and it is true for me: within ten minutes of giving birth, I told my husband I’d never be doing it again. And at the time, I meant it – unequivocally.

However, several months later, I was fortunate enough to have the opportunity to discuss my horrific experience with a hospital midwife. And while that obviously can’t change what happened, it has validated the awful delivery I had, and allowed me to make peace with it.

Every medical decision taken from for me was sound; despite feeling completely out of control, I accept that those who were making calls which affected my body and my baby made every judgement based on our health and welfare.

Yes, I wish it had been a different experience, but we both came out of it alive, and for that I must be thankful.

3. My Daughter’s Well-Being

This is another reason from the first post, which is also relevant to me: my daughter is high-needs. You’d never believe it when we’re at our sing and sign class – I regularly receive remarks about how confident she is (I think they’re compliments, but I do worry she may just be a little annoying to others who don’t adore her as I do!).

Yet at home, she craves almost constant affection and attention – she doesn’t play well by herself; she wants to be held all the time; she’s basically very needy of my complete focus. And while I’m in the fortunate position of being able to provide that for her, I want to continue doing so. After all, (though not everyone will agree with me), my personal view is that you cannot spoil a toddler with too much love.

Should you have a second child? #baby #siblings #family

4. Sleep-Deprivation

This one’s a biggie. I’ve spoken about it many times on the blog.

It’s a surreal experience – with hindsight I can liken it best to a year long episode of living under water. Life becomes a wash of tedium and pressure and exhaustion, as though submerged, the movement is hindered and sound is distorted. The ability to effectively communicate becomes diminished, along with rationale and patience.

My memories are hazy, and it’s easy to forget the depth of my struggles during that time. But I cannot overstate the relief I feel to be through the other side.

So on each (rare – thank GAHD) occasion we regress to a bad night – I just know in my heart:

I. Can’t. Do. It. Again. (Yet.)

5. My Mental Health

One more point which cropped up in the original post: I did suffer from PNA. I have no doubt an incredibly difficult relationship with somebody closely involved with our family attributed to my anxiety and agitation. Having now come out the other side of a desolate year, I’m fearful of returning to that immense strain. It was not good for me or my daughter, but most of all for my marriage.

I want to protect us all from it recurring and the simplest way is to avoid a similar situation. And sadly the trigger for this person’s behaviour was my daughter’s arrival…

6. Our Home

I was spoiled for space in my childhood home. That makes it sound like I come from a rich family, but if you knew the full truth of our circumstances you’d appreciate the irony in that. Suffice to say, we had plenty of space, but otherwise very little.

The point is, I’m used to not living on top of other people. I’m used to a ‘minimalist’ home, quite simply because there was a ton of storage space to keep things neat and tidy and out of sight. See, clutter stresses me out. I wish it didn’t, but it’s one of my foibles: chaotic environment, chaotic head.

I cannot relax in a messy room; I crave visual order, because for me it equals ordered thoughts.

So – in an ideal world, we’d move to a slightly larger home before having a second child. Today, our wardrobe is in the second bedroom due to space-constraints. And absurd though it may seem, I feel a need for my own wardrobe in my own bedroom before I’m ready to commit to another baby!

Should We Have a Second Baby? Bedroom
When my bedroom is this big, THEN I’ll be ready.

7. My business

This feels so arbitrary, or whimsical, or…something. But it’s immensely important to me right now, and hugely significant. Since my daughter was born, I’ve been working hard on turning this blog into a way of generating income while not having to forfeit being a full-time mummy.

So, it may seem trivial – selfish even – but there are layers to this reason.

This blog is an ongoing labour of love, which I’ve poured my heart and soul into; which is coming to fruition; which I am proud of and passionate about; which was a vital part of helping me climb out of that bleakness; which is actually beginning to benefit our family – financially and in terms of wonderful opportunities; which allows me to look after my baby girl myself.

Writing on Laptop

(Here’s yet another layer which has been added since I started writing this piece: I’m in the running to win an award. For the BiBs. That’s blinking HUUUUUGE! It validates the time and effort and desire to succeed.)

And it could all be jeopardised.

If I get the timing wrong, or if I have another Devil Pixie who refuses to sleep, it could all go to ruin. (If there’s any justice, our next one is due to be an Elfin Angel, but there’s really no telling, is there? Update: if I’d only known!)

After all the hours and dedication I’ve devoted to my little blog, the thought of it failing at the last hurdle is simply too much to bear. That may sound melodramatic, but my confidence and sense of worth are all bound up in this project. To suddenly lose that will feel like losing a big chunk of myself.


8. Cost

Neatly tied in to the above point – I know we could cover the expense of a second child with some tweaks to our lives – but wouldn’t it be wonderful if I was in a position to meet any additional outlays with income from my blog? That’s my idyllic vision and what I’m striving to achieve.

9. Biology

I mentioned this in the previous post, and actually, it has been relevant for me. Our daughter is now nearly twenty months old, but it’s only very recently even become possible for us to extend our family. I attribute this to extended breastfeeding, but whatever the underlying cause, physically it’s not been on the cards until now. Probably. (Naturally, I’ve not been foolish enough to assume we were 100% safe, because that would have be akin to sending a gold-embossed invitation to Sod’s Law.)

How to Clear a Clogged Milk Duct

10. Time

And if I’m very honest, that’s been a blessed gift – because I’ve simply not been ready. I think perhaps it’s why this whole subject has suddenly come to the forefront of, well, everything.

The fact that it’s now a viable prospect means it colours all of my thoughts and plans – it’s always there, hanging over us like a rainbow. But, though I know there truly is a pot of gold at its end, there’s no clear route to it.

That rainbow is such a tantalising beacon of hope. And time alone will allow me to navigate my way to all that it promises.

So When Will I Be Ready?

I find it very difficult to pick apart all of the reasons I’ve listed above and neatly sort them into lists of those which are for my benefit, and those which are for my child. It’s a fine balancing act between putting my daughter first, and ensuring I am mentally and emotionally stable/healthy/positive enough for her.

The biggest difference my blog will make to my daughter is not in terms of material loss or gain, but in my general wellbeing. I can’t help but wonder if I should be putting her need for a sibling above that…

Should We Have a Second Baby? Siblings

So, Should I Have Another Baby?

Ultimately, here is my truth:

I want to be pregnant once more; I want to have a second child; I want to experience the newborn phase again – knowing what I know now. I do want all of that…but without the complication of a toddler running around:

I’m broody for the baby who has grown into my little girl.

And I’m not quite ready to return to the chaos. Luckily, I’ll have nine months to get used to the idea. Mental stamina is required to combat the fatigue a child brings, and I’ve spoken before about how I prepared for it in much the same way as I would a long run.

Is it time to push through that metaphorical wall, and finish this marathon I’ve started? Should we have a second baby yet?

An award-nominated blogger and author, Kate is a huge advocate of personal growth, focusing on journaling to increase positivity and facilitate mindful motherhood. With a wealth of experience in breastfeeding and CMPA, Kate is also an expert baby sleep chaser. Her writing has appeared on Mothercare, Huff Post, and BritMums.


  1. What a great post, thanks for sharing. I feel very similar about this situation and its nice to know its not just me that does get happy when the lady times come. I also want all those first feeling again and that lovely newborn stage, but it will be so hard with a toddler in tow, thanks for sharing #TheList

  2. Kate Tunstall Reply

    I do feel like that too – should I just get on with it and I’ll be happy when number two arrives, we’ll make it work…? But them we have another bad night and it terrifies me all over again and I’m back to square one!

    Best of luck, and please let me know when you’ve decided it’s the right choice (I’m sure you will!) – I need a kick up the bum!

    Thanks so much, I really appreciate that xx

  3. Topfivemum Reply

    What a brilliant post! I’ve just had baby number 2 and my eldest is 18 months. We decided to go for it when she was 9 months old – when she was a happy, immobile, cute and cuddly little thing. I fell pregnant immediately whereas first time around took over a year. By month 3 of my pregnancy, DD was walking, tantruming, going through a sleep regression, I was going back to a new full-time job and suddenly thought ‘ohmygodhowoneartharewegoingtodothis’?

    I don’t think there’s ever a right time and I wish I could give some reassurance on the whole coping with a newborn/toddler thing. Maybe once I get over my latest panic attack of ‘ohmygoddon’tgobacktoworkandleavemeonmyownwithtwokids’ when hubby finishes his paternity leave in a week’s time – eek!

    You’ll know when the time is right for you and I must say that, despite everything, seeing my two babies together is so overwhelmingly special, I’m so pleased we didn’t have time to change our minds (which I most certainly would have when my daughter got to 12 months lol!)

    • Kate Tunstall Reply

      Oh wow, congratulations and well done!

      I wish you all the very best, and is genuinely love to hear how you get on.

      I’m sure I’d feel the same way as you if I did it – after all, how can one possibly regret their children once they are here? But I don’t want to be terrified of my second’s arrival; I want to be fully on board and 100% thrilled and excited. I feel I owe it to him/her to wait until I know I can provide the same love as I’ve given my daughter. And right now I’m not sure I have the capacity for more!

      I’m sure it won’t be too long, and I’m sure it will be wonderful when it happens.

      Thanks for commenting ? x

  4. Cassie parish Reply

    Constantly deliberate and discuss this with other mummies I know and hubby. Have come to the conclusion that now isn’t OUR right time but not quite sussed out when that right time will be because we all seem to agree that there’s no such thing lol. It’s like when you knew you was ready for number one though (if planned), I’m sure we’ll know when we are easy for number two.
    Love this and thank you for your honesty. An admirable quality not enough people are quick enough to share.

    • Kate Tunstall Reply

      Thanks Cassie. You’re right there’s no such thing! Maybe it’s a case of working up the courage and then just being brave?! ? I know I’d never regret it, but I also think I owe it to number two to REALLY want them even at the planning stage. X

  5. Kate Tunstall Reply

    Reading a comment like this makes writing my blog so worthwhile. I’m so glad it’s helped you. All the best for whatever your future may hold x

  6. Fiona Cambouropoulos Reply

    I’m not sure there is ever a “right time” it is different for everyone but i did smile through some of those month stages remembering feeling the same #KCACOLS

    • Kate Tunstall Reply

      I met my new nephew yesterday. It made my ovaries ache – especially when they told me how well he’s sleeping already. But I’m just so terrified at the thought of another awful sleeper…

  7. Rebecca | AAUBlog Reply

    This is really interesting – it is so hard when you all have different ideas. thanks so much for linking up to #KCACOLS hope to see you again next week

  8. Kate Tunstall Reply

    I can’t even imagine how hard that would be. I keep wanting to… And then I keep getting scared and putting it off again! I’m sure it will happen soon though… Maybe! ?

  9. Kate Tunstall Reply

    Thanks Becca, I’m not sure it’s helped me make up my mind!

  10. Katy - Hot Pink Wellingtons Reply

    Ah, I’m going through exactly the same thing at the moment – in fact I wrote a very recent post on it too. My son is just over two, and we are only now starting to feel ready. But still there are so many of your list boxes that I was ticking off here. My son is definitely high needs, and although I had a thankfully smooth delivery, I found the whole experience of pregnancy just awful and the thought of facing it all over again with a toddler demanding my attention is just really hard. But I think he’d make a wonderful brother, and ultimately I do really want another child. It’s just the whole question of… is now the right time?! #KCACOLS

    • Kate Tunstall Reply

      YES! Please will you let me know when you’ve decided – and how you reached that decision?! ?

  11. My sister has two kids. She had her second when my nephew was seven. I think that was a genius idea personally. And if yur daughter doesn’t play well on her own, surely it would help to have a sibling around for her to play with?

    • Kate Tunstall Reply

      Every situation is different, I really have no idea what I’ll do today, but that might change tomorrow!

  12. Kate Tunstall Reply

    Sounds like you’re confident in your decision, which is a good place to be! My trouble is knowing that ideally we do want another – but trying to figure out the best time to do it… Thanks for commenting!

  13. Great blog! I can see this was from five years ago so I’m keen to hear your journey since publishing.

    Our baby has just turned one and I’m starting to pine for another however I too struggled with the first 4/5 months mainly due to sleep deprivation and my negative head space at the time which was anxiety, worry & fear, typical first time mum issues.

    I know so much more this time round and I know I could implement things to help with regards to sleep (we hired a sleep consultant so i have a toolkit now!) and I feel so much more confident however my fear is that I want a ‘do over’ which is not possible, my daughter is one now and I’m not getting that time back so I need to accept if we do have another this new ‘season’ will be a newborn again plus a small person to look after, and whilst in some respects I feel I will be a ‘better mum’ this time round thanks to experience I know it will be more demanding having two to look after….

    Luckily our baby slept through from 5 months after the support of the consultant so we have had a good 6 months of evenings to ourselves and sleep, but I’m terrified of sleep deprivation again as it made me depressed and also the challenges of juggling two.

    Keen to know how this chapter turned out for you 🙂

    • Hi Callie,

      So pleased this helped you. A few things spring to mind…

      1. I’m just one person, so while I’m more than happy to share my experiences, they’re only worth so much! 🙂

      2. I’m so pleased a sleep consultant was able to help you. Personally, I don’t believe in them. Babies do what they’re programmed to do and while you can absolutely put good routines etc in place, there are never guarantees. This post might help you if you’re interested.

      But going back to your comments about a ‘do over’ – I can totally relate to this. For me, my second delivery was very healing after a traumatic first. Sadly, my second daughter ended up with colic due to allergies, and it meant life became extremely difficult for a very long time. Her sleep has always been horrendous and at (just) 4, she still wakes up before 5.30am every day.

      Due to the CMPA which had many implications, I found being a mum of two very tough. I’d anticipated it, but it was still a pretty dark period in those early months. Of course we were unlucky, it’s been a medical issue. Hopefully the same would apply for you, but I’m being honest because my point is that you just never know how things will work out.

      Despite how hard it’s been at times, one thing that holds true and I’m confident this will be true almost always, in every situation – it’s worth it. You’ll never regret having another baby to love.

      Hand on heart, had I known what was coming I probably wouldn’t have had the courage to have my second daughter. But I cannot imagine life without her and so thank goodness I didn’t know. She is an absolute joy (and a terror!).

      All the very best. <3

Write A Comment